The Truth Is Out There: Review of "The Bush Agenda"
by Nicholas Carby-Denning
50 Years Is Enough Network
“The Truth is Out There” was the catchphrase of the popular TV show
The X-Files, in which FBI agents exposed the secrets of a
shadowy government conspiracy. With the web of deception the Bush administration has
constructed around the invasion and occupation of Iraq from the WMD wild goose
chase to unauthorized government wiretaps and scandals at Guantanamo Bay and Abu
Ghraib one might feel we need a pair of near-psychic detectives to uncover the
many agendas of the Bush administration.
Fortunately we have Antonia Juhasz who, in her exhaustively
researched, well-detailed and eminently readable book The Bush
Agenda: Invading the World One Economy at a Time, shows us the truth that is
out there. In The Bush Agenda, Juhasz clearly and concisely
plots the players, connections, motives, winners and losers in the Bush
administration’s military and economic policy. Juhasz also takes great care to place
what is glibly called the “Bush Agenda,” but is more importantly the
culmination of decades of neo-conservative planning and maneuvering, in historic
context.
The invasion and reconstruction of Iraq follows a clear formula
written by and benefiting top members and allies of the Bush administration, and swathed
in a mass of rhetoric about “democracy,” “freedom,” and
“security.” Their agenda is an imperial one, combining military supremacy
with economic dominance and based on uncontested U.S. power in both realms.
Juhasz’ timely book exposes how this agenda has instead led to increased
insecurity and inequality for Iraqis and Americans alike and made a mockery of the
democratic process, through enforcing the same set of policies that institutions like the
World Bank have been pushing on countries around the world for decades.
In the Beginning: Pax Americana
Juhasz traces the ideological lineage of the invasion, occupation
and reconstruction of Iraq to the idea of Pax Americana (a
reference to Pax Romana), the notion that world peace could
be brought about by the hegemonic rule of a militarily and economically dominant empire.
Pax Americana was conceived of by various authors, with
many in the Bush administration including Vice President Dick Cheney, former Deputy
Defense Secretary and current World Bank president Paul Wolfowitz, Secretary of Defense
Donald Rumsfeld, former Secretary of State Colin Powell, Secretary of State Condoleezza
Rice, U.S. Ambassador to Iraq Zalmay Khalilzad and Lewis “Scooter” Libby
whose paths have crossed in the State Department, the Department of Defense, and
various think tanks over the past three decades.
After the fall of the Soviet Union, the authors of Pax Americana supported the continuation of the war economy,
envisioning, in their own words, “a world order backed by the U.S.” such
that, “other nations are discouraged from ever challenging the established political
and economic order.”
The Bush Agenda and Pax Americana
span> are unique in that the administration has explicitly tied economic policy to military
expansion in the context of “The War on Terror”. After September 11th,
former U.S. Trade Representative Robert Zoellick under George W. Bush even went so far
as to say that the U.S. would be “countering terror with trade.” For Juhasz,
the occupation and reconstruction of Iraq is the ultimate realization of Pax Americana
the complete economic transformation of a country at gunpoint, and the
reassertion of U.S. hegemony in the region.
The Economic Agenda: Winners & Losers
The reconstruction of Iraq under U.S. direction has led to a
drastic, unilateral, and undemocratic rewriting of Iraqi law, reflecting the most extreme
adherence to neo-liberal economic policy. As with the military side of the Bush agenda,
the economic components are hardly news. In The Bush Agenda Juhasz explains that U.S.-
directed economic reforms in Iraq are the continuation of a long history of disastrous
economic policies dictated to impoverished countries by the World Bank, IMF, and the WTO
policies which have depressed growth and increased global poverty and inequality.
Through Paul Bremer’s dictatorial Orders the U.S. rewrote the Iraqi constitution to
including some of the most extreme and controversial provisions on foreign investment,
privatization and foreign ownership (Order 39), tax structure (Order 37) and intellectual
property rights (Order 80) ever instituted to make Iraq in the words of the Financial Times,
“one of the most liberalized economies in the developing world.”
Time and time again, the real winners of neo-liberal economics
are corporations who are given unprecedented flexibility with virtually no accountability
for their actions. In the case of Iraq, Juhasz exposes close ties between the authors of the
Bush agenda and a handful of corporations with long histories in Iraq including Bechtel,
Chevron, Halliburton and Lockheed Martin. American corporations and those four
in particular have been the recipients of huge sums of money to rebuild Iraq, but
their efforts have largely been a failure and Bush has neither held them accountable nor
demanded the money back.
Before the first Gulf War the World Health Organization (WHO)
reported that 90% of Iraqis had abundant safe drinking water, but in May 2004 the UN
estimated 80% of families used unsafe water. The U.S. Agency for International
Development (USAID) reported that, a year and a half after Bechtel entered Iraq, “(w)
ater meant for consumption is pumped through a system largely untreated while raw
waste flows untreated directly into city streets, rivers and marshes.” In December
2005 electricity output nationally was only 60% of the level the U.S. had promised for July
2004. Infuriatingly, though 93% of U.S. funds have been distributed, as many as 30% of
electricity projects and 60% of water and sewage projects will not be completed. Finally,
while the U.S. has appropriated $30 billion for Iraqi reconstruction by U.S. corporations,
Juhasz argues using the Iraqi companies and local expertise reconstruction could be run
more efficiently and at 90% less cost!
Uprooting Terror or Sowing Its Seeds?
Not only is the Bush agenda enriching close friends and allies of
the Bush administration at the expense of Iraqi and American citizens, but it is also
exacerbating those conditions that breed terrorist acts such as those that occurred on
September 11, 2001. In The Bush Agenda, Juhasz cites the CIA, which in 2000 predicted a
rise in insecurity as a result of increased economic inequality.
“The rising tide of the global economy will create many
economic winners but it will not lift all boats… [It will] spawn conflicts at home and
abroad, ensuring an even wider gap between regional winners and losers than exists
today… Regions, countries and groups feeling left behind will face deepening
economic stagnation, political instability and cultural alienation… They will foster
political, ethnic, ideological, and religious extremism.”
In 2005 the CIA again predicted a “more pervasive sense
of insecurity, including terrorism… the gap between the ‘haves’ and
the ‘have nots’ will widen… The key factors which spawn terrorism
show no signs of abating over the next fifteen years.” U.S.-imposed economic
reforms in Iraq continue despite these dire warnings from the government’s own
intelligence agency.
In addition, the failure of Iraqi reconstruction has created more
instability in the region. Juhasz notes that 80% of Iraqis believe insurgents fight because
they think the U.S. is stealing Iraq’s wealth. Bremer’s orders have led to
increased unemployment in Iraq and preferences foreign contractors to Iraqi businesses,
leading both to the failure of many projects and to a recognition of the
“reconstruction” as an occupation. The Bush administration is not following
a security agenda but an economic one.
Uncovering a Conspiracy or Pointing Out the Obvious?
The U.S. Department of Defense concluded in 2004 that Muslims
don’t hate freedom or democracy, but rather are opposed to U.S. foreign policy
which seems to be motivated by “ulterior motives.” If there was any doubt
remaining as to ulterior motives for the War on Iraq, Antonia Juhasz has dispelled it by
laying out the facts of the case revealing the covert political and economic agenda behind
U.S. foreign policy.
The greatest strength of Juhasz’s book is that it points
out what should be obvious to everyone. With an administration so closely tied to the U.S.
corporations being handed contracts in Iraq there is more than a little conflict of interest.
Juhasz also provides a clear agenda on what should be done to fix the situation: we should
be doing what we promised financing reconstruction but ceding control of
the reconstruction and its benefits to the Iraqis. We should be supporting Iraqi businesses
and workers, rather than undermining their national development, auctioning off
assistance and prime sectors to bidders closest to the Bush administration.
In Juhasz’s expert hands, the Bush agenda is clear; her
book cuts through the rhetoric of “freedom” and “free trade”
and the Iraq invasion is exposed as part of an imperial endeavor and the perfect marriage
of military and economic extortion. Juhasz has given us a blueprint of the Bush
administration, complete with details of its inspiration, its adherents and its intertwined
assemblage of government and corporate actors. This book is required reading for all who
want a peek into the future of U.S. imperialism and the facts and analysis to stand up in
defense of human rights around the world.
|